+- MW Forum (https://www.themwboard.com)
+-- Forum: My Category (https://www.themwboard.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: My Forum (https://www.themwboard.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: MMOEXP-MLB The Show 25 Power Rankings: The Ultimate Infielder Tier List (/showthread.php?tid=4639)
MMOEXP-MLB The Show 25 Power Rankings: The Ultimate Infielder Tier List - sheliepaley - 10-21-2025
In MLB The Show 25, building a competitive team starts with locking down your infield. Your infielders are the backbone of both your defense and your run prevention, and choosing the right players can make the difference between a playoff-caliber squad and one that struggles to hold opponents at bay. With updated ratings, new animations, and MLB The Show25 Stubs improved defensive mechanics in The Show 25, not all infielders are created equal. This guide breaks down the top performers by tier, helping you make informed decisions when drafting, upgrading, or trading for your roster.
Understanding Tier Placement
Infielders in MLB The Show 25 are typically evaluated across several key attributes:
Fielding (FLD): Ability to make plays cleanly and consistently.
Arm Strength and Accuracy (ARM): Critical for turning double plays and nailing runners at bases.
Speed (SPD): Determines range and ability to cover gaps.
Hitting Stats (Contact, Power, Plate Discipline): Important for offensive contributions.
Position Flexibility: Some players can cover multiple infield positions effectively.
Tier lists categorize players based on a combination of these metrics, gameplay impact, and current meta relevance. For this breakdown, we'll use a traditional tier format: S-tier (elite), A-tier (highly effective), B-tier (solid but situational), and C-tier (useful depth).
S-Tier Infielders
S-tier players are the gold standard in MLB The Show 25. These are elite talents who excel defensively, contribute offensively, and have the athleticism to impact every play.
Marcus Semien (2B): With outstanding fielding and range, Semien is a double-play machine. His bat is versatile, providing both contact and moderate power, making him a reliable presence at the plate.
Francisco Lindor (SS): One of the most complete shortstops in the game. Lindor combines incredible defensive agility with excellent arm strength, plus a potent bat capable of clutch hits.
Rafael Devers (3B): Devers brings elite power to third base, capable of clearing fences consistently. Defensively, he's strong enough to handle hot shots down the line and make diving stops.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (1B): A force in the middle of the lineup, Guerrero Jr. dominates with his raw power while providing solid, reliable fielding at first base.
S-tier infielders can anchor any team, giving you confidence on both sides of the ball. They are typically worth investing in through upgrades, stubs, or card pulls because their impact justifies the cost.
A-Tier Infielders
A-tier infielders are highly effective but may have minor weaknesses compared to S-tier players. They can excel in specific situations or offer versatility across multiple positions.
Bo Bichette (SS/2B): Excellent speed and fielding range, with above-average contact hitting. Slightly less power than Lindor, but still a threat offensively.
Jose Ramirez (3B/2B): Versatile with the ability to play both second and third, Ramirez offers balanced offensive contributions. Defensive ratings are strong but not elite.
Matt Chapman (3B): A defensive wizard, Chapman is incredible at turning double plays and snagging tough grounders. His bat is slightly less potent than Devers but still very effective.
Paul Goldschmidt (1B): Consistent power hitter with reliable fielding. Goldschmidt is slightly slower than S-tier first basemen, but his offensive ceiling is excellent.
A-tier infielders are excellent starting options, especially for teams that need depth or flexibility. They shine in clutch moments and often outperform higher-rated but less balanced S-tier options in certain matchups.
B-Tier Infielders
B-tier players are solid contributors but may have notable weaknesses, such as reduced speed, inconsistent defense, or limited offensive output. They are ideal for bench depth, platoon roles, or as cost-effective solutions in RTTS or Diamond Dynasty.
Gleyber Torres (2B/SS): Strong bat, moderate defensive skills. Occasionally struggles with range on the infield.
Josh Donaldson (3B): Power hitter capable of changing the game offensively, but slower and more prone to defensive miscues.
C.J. Cron (1B): Provides reliable power but limited range and defensive mobility. Best suited for DH or first base-only roles.
Andrelton Simmons (SS): Defensive stalwart with elite fielding ratings but limited offensive production. Useful for teams prioritizing defense over hitting.
B-tier players are situational. They can be very effective when used correctly, but relying on them as the core of your infield may create vulnerabilities against top-tier competition.
C-Tier Infielders
C-tier infielders fill roles primarily for depth or specific matchups. They are generally limited either defensively, offensively, or both.
Miguel Rojas (2B/SS): Defensive reliability but minimal offensive threat.
Nico Hoerner (3B/2B): Speed and fielding are decent, but lacks power and high-contact hitting consistency.
Anthony Rizzo (1B): Reliable bat but reduced defensive mobility and range at first base.
C-tier options are best used as utility players, pinch-hitters, or replacements in case of injury. They provide coverage without significantly weakening your squad but should rarely see starting roles in competitive settings.
Final Thoughts
Building an elite infield in MLB The Show 25 requires balancing defensive reliability, offensive power, and positional flexibility. S-tier infielders like Francisco Lindor, Marcus Semien, and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. serve as anchors, while A-tier and B-tier players add depth and versatility. Understanding each player's strengths and weaknesses ensures that you can construct an infield capable of handling every game scenario, from clutch late innings to extended extra-inning battles.
By using this tier list, you can optimize your roster for Diamond Dynasty, RTTS, or online modes, maximizing both your defensive coverage and offensive potential. Remember, infielders are more than just defensive placeholders - they can change the course of a game with timely double plays, clutch hits, and cheap MLB The Show Stubs smart positioning. Choose wisely, and your team will dominate on both sides of the ball.